SMALL ISLAND. LARGE EXPECTATIONS.
Unofficial guidance desk

Ask Donnie

Questions about Skye, travel, weather, midges or matters requiring the confidence of a man who owns several lengths of rope.

“There’s an answer to most things. Whether it helps is a separate matter.”— Donnie
Illustrated fictional portrait of Donnie holding a mug of tea
Send a question

What would you like to know?

Genuine questions are welcome. Donnie’s replies may contain useful local knowledge, unnecessary confidence or both.

Questions are reviewed before publication. Contact details remain private and may be used only to reply about your question.
The advice so far

Previously Asked

Published only after inspection by someone with access to the password.

Asked by William

This, believe it or not, is a genuine inquiry. "Why doesn't the Tourist Board enroll the services of one or two of the more senior sheep on Skye to the management comittee as pro-bono consultants"? One feels a great deal of expertise, especially in the area of traffic management and eating establishments, is squandered by the Board being run by people who,(how can I say this without offending), know bugger all about local issues. Yours, with respectful apologies, A Blackie.

Donnie replies

Dear A. Blackie, Thank you for what I can only describe as a long-overdue and surprisingly well-written proposal. We have, in fact, been considering appointing two senior sheep as advisers. Their qualifications are exceptional: extensive knowledge of local roads, an instinctive understanding of passing-place occupancy, and decades of experience entering eating establishments without a reservation. The main difficulty is that both candidates have refused to attend meetings unless held on the A87 during the morning rush. Murdo supports the appointments. He says the Board would benefit from a few members who know when to keep their mouths shut. Can I ask, whether “pro bono” means we won’t have to pay them. The sheep have requested grazing rights, travel expenses and a salt lick. Negotiations are progressing normally.

Asked by Tamsin

Good afternoon Donnie. I trust you have been drinking plenty of tea and eating biscuits. This brings me to my question. I’d like to climb in the Cuillins. Is it true that chocolate hobnobs be the snack of choice, or is it all butter shortbread? I already have a good supply of Talisker so I’m fine for being appropriately hydrated. Thank you.

Donnie replies

Yes, Hobnobs are the sensible choice for the Cuillins because they’ll survive being sat on, dropped in a rucksack and briefly exposed to Highland weather. Shortbread is better for morale, but structurally less dependable. As for the Talisker, I would recommend keeping that for after the climb. Murdo says this is because the Cuillins already move about enough on their own.

Asked by Tommy

Is the Skye midge the worst midge on the Islands? I’m sure Tiree has that title?

Donnie replies

I would say that this is a highly contentious subject and best not discussed after two drams. Skye midges insist they are the most persistent. Tiree’s claim they are more athletic and have better wind resistance. Murdo says the only fair test is to stand between the islands in shorts and see who finds you first.

Asked by Jill

How do the men in kilts manage to stay calm and focused when it’s midge season. Some areas of their body must be so painful.

Donnie replies

Donnie says calmness comes with experience. A good kilt gives the midges plenty of access, but very little certainty about where they’ll end up, which keeps everyone alert. The traditional defence is a combination of midge repellent, strategic movement and never standing still long enough for a full committee to form. Murdo says the sporran is mainly there to protect the important paperwork.

Asked by Mairi

Donnie do you know who owns that sheep on Mill road?

Donnie replies

I know who thinks they own it. The sheep has taken a different position on the matter and has been representing itself since March. If it’s the one standing in the middle of the road, that’s Morag. Don’t challenge her. She has right of way and knows it.